Jump to content

T_Thomas

Members
  • Posts

    7
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by T_Thomas

  1. Dang, Senor - who peed in your Wheaties? I was trying my best to be appreciative and complimentary for all of your help. I came over here to post because I read here frequently, and I wanted to get a more "expert" view than from the other site. At the time I posed the questions, the guys on the other site hadn't yet offered up those rule cites. I cut & pasted those references - excuse me for not verifying the syntax. Oh, by-the-way, it was not me who posted that original question with the "very ungrammatical English" - you can chastise Guest Jacob for that transgression. I'm pretty sure that I never mentioned the term "abandonment" either. Thank Jacob for that one too. Oh, and maybe I am "misinterpreting" 2019 NFHS Case Book Play 9.1.1 Situation D (did I get that worded properly?), but in that quote it does not seem at all clear to me that it applies if the batter-runner never does go to first base. Maybe because it actually says "(b) B5 goes to second base but fails to touch first base." I don't know, please excuse my ignorance... But Thanks. I sincerely do appreciate you and the others for taking your time to help.
  2. Thanks, guys. Senior Azul, your casebook play above makes it clear he can be out on appeal if he advances past the base without touching, but in the OP he never goes there at all. Below is a summary of the suppositions on the other site. (Thanks to the other posters there for helping provide some of the references.) Article 8 Penalty (quoted below) says a runner can be out on appeal for failure to touch either advancing or returning 8.2 1. an advancing runner must touch 1 2 3 H in order ... 5. If a runner who misses any base ... desires to return to touch the base must do so immediately Penalty: For failure to touch a base (advancing or returning) ... the runner may be called out if an appeal is made by the defensive team ... on the last play of the game an appeal can be made until the umpire(s) leave the field of play. So in this case the batter / runner could be called out on appeal for not advancing to first. The question then becomes "When can you call him out?" Under appeal procedures 8.2.6.d.2 A runner may not return to touch a missed base if … he has left the field of play. So he can be called out when he crosses the boundary to dead ball territory. So - back to the OP ... IF the defensive team is quick enough to make an appeal before the umpires leave the field, the umpires should just direct the batter-runner to touch 1B. IF the batter-runner is already in the dugout at time of appeal, then 3rd Out, No Run, Play On. Problem solved, right?.
  3. Original situation was High School under Fed rules, but I'm interested if there are differences in other rule sets.
  4. So, is this the definitive answer on this? Just direct the batter to go to first after the celebration? What if the batter runner leaves the field, but the other coach protests while his players or the umpires are still on the field? how would you handle the appeal and subsequent protest? Nobody has any other interpretations or case logic to apply?
  5. T_Thomas

    basi balk question

    OK, I'm not exactly disagreeing, and you guys are right that most would balk this move. But... help me understand why. The rules do not differentiate between LHP or RHP. A LHP can obviously begin his pitching delivery and then go to 1st Base at the last second, as long as the foot does not cross behind the rubber and he steps "toward" 1B. Why can a RHP not make the same motion? Would you also balk a LHP on a move to 3B if he picked up the right knee regularly and then spun to step and throw to 3b? Is this just accepted custom, like the jump turn / jab step? Thanks
  6. I'm gonna bet that no one in the history of that field has ever hit one out of the park. Looks to be about 320' on the lines. Possible. I get about 283 to RF pole and 297 to LF pole - still pretty good pokes for 13-14 year old eighth-graders
×
×
  • Create New...