Heres the situation: This was a 11-12yr old game. Runner on 3rd. Wild pitch by the pitcher so the Runner on 3rd takes off to try to steal home. Well it takes a nice bounce off the back stop so F2 grabbed it, set up infront of the plate and put the tag down so the runner would slide right into it. So the runner slid into it and hurt the catcher wrist. The catcher pulled his hand out of the glove immediatly after the tag was layed and the ball popped out while taking his hand out of the glove. I called him OUT. Well the coach tryed to argue that he dropped the ball. I said "i didnt see it that way, he had control while he was laying the tag."
So would you guys have called him safe?
One other thing, although the kid above layed the tag correctly, at this age i notice that alot of kids still try to tag runners that are sliding on the chest. If the ball beats the kid there do you call him safe or out?