Just happened to see a critical miss by the PU in this game (NJ vs PA).
Situation - NJ has based loaded with one out, down 2-1 in the first inning. Batter hits high chopper toward the pitcher, who fields and attempts to beat R3 to the plate for the force. R3 clearly reached the plate prior to the pitcher's arrival, but was called out.
I've had many bangers like this over the years and we all, on occasion, miss a close one. This one wasn't even close. The next batter struck out and a potentially big inning for NJ was thwarted.
I'm not associated with either team, so no bias here.
I felt badly for the PU whose critical error was shown via instant replay to the viewers.
My point is that without knowing anything about the PU, an experienced, seasoned umpire would not miss a call like this. What is the criteria for the selection of these umpires?
