I am a board president of a private, non-profit youth sports organization. My goal is to ultimately grow my organization in ALL sports, but baseball has proven to be the most difficult due to some of the Little League boundary requirements. Our organization is in partnership with a government parks and rec department that seemingly requires us to participate in LL with them. As far as the overall LL experience is concerned, the baseball itself seems to be going great. The kid's are having fun and the opportunity, although rarely ever a reality for our teams, to compete in a season end tournament keeps the parents happy.
Where we are running into an issue with our local LL board has to do with boundary restrictions. We are right on the border (less than a mile away) of 2 other boundaries. In all other sports, because we are a private non-profit, kids are allowed to sign up, but must pay an additional fee (an out of county fee to cover tax dollars that are used to improve our park). However, in baseball we are forced to turn away so many kids that could literally walk to our park.
My question to the experienced baseball people in this forum: If we have an "out of county" 8+ year old that wants to sign up to play rec baseball at our organization, but agrees to forego All Star selection at the conclusion of the season be prohibited from playing? It would seem to me that the boundaries are there to prevent organizations from stacking their all-star teams, which I fully support and understand. My issue arises when you have a kid who is just trying to play rec baseball for fun and is not concerned with all-stars. Our waiver requests are getting denied left and right from our local board chair, which also raises the question about whether the waiver process even has a purpose. We have told the LL board that all out of county kids have been told they are not eligible for all-stars, but it doesn't seem to matter to whoever is in charge.
From a youth sports perspective, this is counter productive to growing the sport. Kids want to have fun and play with their friends. If LL is denying them that opportunity based on where they live then they may have just lost a kid to another sport, or worse, no sport. It feels like common sense to me, A NON BASEBALL GUY, that it shouldn't matter where you play if it doesn't impact all-star selection.
Please help me understand.