Play at the plate

[noumpere]

5 hours ago, MadMax said:

 In this case, the Runner is (incorrectly) judging that the plate is probably beneath or just adjacent to F2.

 

You think that this is OBS because F2 deked the runner into thinking the plate was somewhere other than it's actual location?  That's not a reason for OBS (absent some thirld-world play of covering the plate with dirt and using spray paint to draw a new plate up the line, etc)

[MadMax]

8 hours ago, noumpere said:

You think that this is OBS because F2 deked the runner into thinking the plate was somewhere other than it's actual location?  That's not a reason for OBS (absent some thirld-world play of covering the plate with dirt and using spray paint to draw a new plate up the line, etc)

No, never said he deked him.

I said I'd have OBS if that – that set-up position in the first photo – is where he really did set up prior to the throw inbound.