Play at first - Replay

[Thunderheads]

Nope .....

Also, ...on the replay where they show the wide angle and Kinsler scoring ....why doesn't PU make a call there?

[noumpere]

 

Also, ...on the replay where they show the wide angle and Kinsler scoring ....why doesn't PU make a call there?

He starts to, but since the third out was called at frist, there's no need to do so.

 

It's similar to a steal on a ball 4 / check swing situation -- note the call, but don't make it until the check swing is ruled on.

[Thunderheads]

He starts to, but since the third out was called at frist, there's no need to do so.

 

It's similar to a steal on a ball 4 / check swing situation -- note the call, but don't make it until the check swing is ruled on.

thanks, that makes sense

[Umpire in Chief]

I was watching this game on TV last night. Wow, what a banger. I don't have audio here at work, so it may be in the clip, but they later read a statement form the replay office, that there was no video proof available to overturn the call.

[stkjock]

@Umpire in Chief - are those statements from the replay office available someplace?

[Thunderheads]

I was watching this game on TV last night. Wow, what a banger. I don't have audio here at work, so it may be in the clip, but they later read a statement form the replay office, that there was no video proof available to overturn the call.

the proof is in the OP

[Cav]

It's was a no-doubt-about-it out in my games...but then again, in my games, F6 wouldn't have come up with the ball in the first place. 

[Thunderheads]

It's was a no-doubt-about-it out in my games...but then again, in my games, F6 wouldn't have come up with the ball in the first place. 

Lol, very true! :-) but, in your situation the ball never gets to the first baseman, so he's safe regardless. Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

[Richvee]

I like the non-reversal here. It's so close...I don't see anything definitive in the replays.  I think any non-Tiger fan would agree. 

[zoops]

So let's say this was overturned and F3 didn't throw home because of the call being the 3rd out, would they put R2 (or whatever you'd call him at this point) at 3rd?  Is it umpire discretion on where they think the runners would have ended up?

[ricka56]

So let's say this was overturned and F3 didn't throw home because of the call being the 3rd out, would they put R2 (or whatever you'd call him at this point) at 3rd?  Is it umpire discretion on where they think the runners would have ended up?

Good question...its an example of an unfixable situation.
I think it would be up to the umpire(s) discretion... probably with crap on both ends of the stick.