Replay review ...out?

[Thunderheads]

Convincing evidence?  Maybe, maybe not, but ........upon review, I don't have an out either ....

[gnhbua93]

That call needs to go to the statistics as confirmed, not as stands!

[UmpJeff]

This call needs to go to the statistics as overturned...in my book, anyway.

 

The announcers are killing me again!  I was unaware of the rule that ties go to the runner.

Edited July 31, 2015 by UmpJeff

[Thunderheads]

This call needs to go to the statistics as overturned...in my book, anyway.

ok, so it's not just me ?!?!?

[UmpJeff]

ok, so it's not just me ?!?!?

I think the first angle clearly shows BR beat the throw.

[BillKen]

Ties go to the umpire...and umpires reward great defense!

[Jimurray]

This call needs to go to the statistics as overturned...in my book, anyway.

 

The announcers are killing me again!  I was unaware of the rule that ties go to the runner.

You should be aware that in OBR, semantically, a tie does go to the runner at !B and any forced base. Practically speaking, @BillKen is correct.

[UmpJeff]

You should be aware that in OBR, semantically, a tie does go to the runner at !B and any forced base. Practically speaking, @BillKen is correct.

I agree.  He's right.  

I should have used the Sarcasm Alert emoticon after my last sentence .

[ricka56]

There is lots umpire issues to discuss, "arguing" a safe/out call that you need 3 slo-mo replays to form an opinion on, isn't one of them.  

[Thunderheads]

There is lots umpire issues to discuss, "arguing" a safe/out call that you need 3 slo-mo replays to form an opinion on, isn't one of them.  

replay is one of the biggest changes in umpiring .... it's certainly relevant .....

[Richvee]

If  we can't agree a day later, it's too close to overturn. Same should go for NY. If they can't tell for sure in 30 seconds the call on the field was wrong, then it should stand.