Review at first overturned .....

[Thunderheads 3,079]

Holladay looked safe in real speed, .....close, but he was indeed safe upon replay review .....

 

but ... why does Carpenter NOT score ??

 

http://m.mlb.com/video/topic/63817564/v36382617

[Chip 41]

Carpenter is only about 20 feet off of 3rd, it appears, when the call is made. Hard to conclusively score him on that, I think.

[Thunderheads 3,079]

Carpenter is only about 20 feet off of 3rd, it appears, when the call is made. Hard to conclusively score him on that, I think.

understood ...but .........2 outs,...he's running on contact ........

[noumpere 3,273]

 

Carpenter is only about 20 feet off of 3rd, it appears, when the call is made. Hard to conclusively score him on that, I think.

understood ...but .........2 outs,...he's running on contact ........

 

He's running, but he's starting from second.  On a clean play in the infield, no way a runner from second scores (or at least not enough that you're going to award him home on this play.)

[Thunderheads 3,079]

 

 

Carpenter is only about 20 feet off of 3rd, it appears, when the call is made. Hard to conclusively score him on that, I think.

understood ...but .........2 outs,...he's running on contact ........

 

He's running, but he's starting from second.  On a clean play in the infield, no way a runner from second scores (or at least not enough that you're going to award him home on this play.)

 

I understand .......they were discussing it last night on the broadcast .........thought it may be a decent discussion point

[Jimurray 901]

Don't slide into 1B. You might hurt something and there is more chance the umpire will get it wrong.

[grayhawk 3,710]

Carpenter is easily out at home if F3 makes even a decent throw.

[umpstu 1,167]

Carpenter is easily out at home if F3 makes even a decent throw.

Even as a Cardinal fan I have to agree with this.