Throw to second....................................

[Thunderheads]

http://mlb.mlb.com/video/play.jsp?content_id=26949431&topic_id=9782246&c_id=mlb&tcid=vpp_copy_26949431&v=3

 

[BigUmpire]

OOPs

[Haid D' Salaami]

Great, i say Again Great positioning on this play.

[Mike Prince]

Great, i say Again Great positioning on this play.

 

I agree.  There was one place to be and U2 was there.

[JaxRolo]

Out by a mile and a half!

[Jimurray]

Great, i say Again Great positioning on this play.

That would be deep B in 3,4 man (unless forced to C in college due to LH batter) with R1. Still see some pros in C.

[HeadHunterLA]

Nope.

[hbk314]

Out by a mile and a half!

 

You must be seeing I'm not, because I certainly don't have him conclusively out. I'd be more inclined to say he was safe.

[UMP45]

 

Great, i say Again Great positioning on this play.

That would be deep B in 3,4 man (unless forced to C in college due to LH batter) with R1. Still see some pros in C.

 

Position depends on left/right handed batter or where the umpire feels most comfortable. 

[Richvee]

U2 had the best angle. He blocked our view of the best replay. Throw was perfect. Kudos to the Giants broadcast team there...Honest and correct commentary. 

[Haid D' Salaami]

 

 

Great, i say Again Great positioning on this play.

That would be deep B in 3,4 man (unless forced to C in college due to LH batter) with R1. Still see some pros in C.

 

Position depends on left/right handed batter or where the umpire feels most comfortable. 

 

in 4 man it doesnt make a difference which hand the batter is. It is up to them on which side they are on.. 2nd base side or 3rd base side. But i can show you the benefits of the 2nd base side or "deep B".. the B side is way better and if shown properly you will never work on the 3rd base side again.. ( unless directed to )

[carolinablue]

Never let a good throw go to waste.

[IABlue]

That guy was toast.

 

Great defensive play.

[zm1283]

 

 

 

Great, i say Again Great positioning on this play.

That would be deep B in 3,4 man (unless forced to C in college due to LH batter) with R1. Still see some pros in C.

 

Position depends on left/right handed batter or where the umpire feels most comfortable. 

 

in 4 man it doesnt make a difference which hand the batter is. It is up to them on which side they are on.. 2nd base side or 3rd base side. But i can show you the benefits of the 2nd base side or "deep B".. the B side is way better and if shown properly you will never work on the 3rd base side again.. ( unless directed to )

 

 

The "Deep C" position is by far my least favorite position or mechanic in 3-man umpiring.  I detest it.

[johnnyg08]

in 4 man it doesnt make a difference which hand the batter is. It is up to them on which side they are on.. 2nd base side or 3rd base side. But i can show you the benefits of the 2nd base side or "deep B".. the B side is way better and if shown properly you will never work on the 3rd base side again.. ( unless directed to )

Agree with this 100%

[hbk314]

Very close play, but he was safe.

[Dannytheman]

I have him safe easily.  But I am a Phillies fan.

[mstaylor]

I have him safe easily.  But I am a Phillies fan.

Could be worse, could be a Mets fan.

[BigUmpire]

I have him safe easily.  But I am a Phillies fan.

Could be worse, could be a Mets fan. Nothing is worse than that.

[carolinablue]

 

 

I have him safe easily.  But I am a Phillies fan.

Could be worse, could be a Mets fan. Nothing is worse than that.

 

 

I don't know, you could be THE Marlins fan.

[tldavis19]

 

 

I have him safe easily.  But I am a Phillies fan.

Could be worse, could be a Mets fan. Nothing is worse than that.

 

Yankees fan......