Jump to content

humanbackstop19

Established Member
  • Content Count

    131
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

37 Neutral

About humanbackstop19

  • Birthday 07/24/1982

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    Decorah, IA

More information about you

  • Your Association Name
    NCAA D III, NCAA, IHSAA, CBUA
  • Occupation
    Teacher
  • Types/Levels of Baseball called
    HS, NCAA, NJCAA
  • How did you hear about Umpire-Empire?
    Referred a member

Recent Profile Visitors

902 profile views
  1. NCAA RULE: 8-3-h If a fair ball goes over the fence in flight or is prevented from going over by being touched by a spectator or by a fielder’s detached equipment, all runners, including the batter, are entitled to score; Note: If a batted ball hits the top of the fence while in fair territory and then bounces over the fence, it is a home run.
  2. Catchers are always asking for time to relay signs to defense in R3/R1 situations. I'll usually grant it the first time, then tell them we need to keep that ball in play the rest of the game for that - no further explanation unless asked.
  3. Not sure what the batter's ox rule is in softball. But, I'm requesting the batter to remain in the box if the P is set and ready for play. I'll verbalize, "The ball is in play", the same I do if the hitter requests time and I don't grant it.
  4. If you're anywhere close to the 5'10"=5'11" range like I am, the All Star System Seven is outstanding! Superior collar bone protection. I will say with a thicker neck, it may be problematic, but fits me like a glove!
  5. Neither FED or OBR books clearly define "tag". However, NCAA defines a tag as: (abbreviated) "touching a runner with the ball or with the glove while holding the ball securely and firmly in that hand or glove" That definition makes a physical contact with the glove necessary. In the Baez play, he never actually touches the runner. He only fakes having possession of the ball. FED does declare a runner out when : 8-4-h: is touched by a live ball securely held by a fielder or is touched by a fielder's glove or hand with the live ball held thierin, while a baserunner is not touching his base. Simply put, Baez never touched the guy, so how is it a tag, real or fake? I do agree that you could call type 2 OBS as the runner was coming back into second base and Baez impeded his progress there. It would be a huge stretch to award third on this play.
  6. I do it for the primary purpose of warming up my brain to listen for the ball in the mitt and watch for the foot. Obviously, there is no foot coming, but it gets you ready. Also, reading arm strength and accuracy of infielders; reading the ball out of their hand on throws that will take the first baseman off the bag.
  7. I disagree. RLI interference is TOP due to the fact the BR did not reach safely to first base, same as FPSR interference. In fact, it's the same penalty, under the same section of the rule book. 8-4: "Runner is Out" Art. 2 a. - Penalty: The runner is out. Interference is called and the ball is dead immediately. On a force-play slide with less than 2 outs, the runner is declared out, as is the BR. Runners shall return to the bases occupied at the time of the pitch.........(This pertains to all interference occurring before BR reaches 1st base) Our association in Iowa discussed this rule in detail and was told this wording applied to both scenarios, FPSR (which was the emphasis of discussion) and RLI, because they are in the same section. Chalk it up to another badly worded FED Rulebook issue.
  8. So, I stand corrected. The CC could not review this on his own as it was only the 6th inning. The CC can only post a review on his own in the final 2 innings of regulation or extra innings. So, fault really comes down to the HC not posting a challenge. That will be the NCAA's "out" on this play, and I don't necessarily disagree with it.
  9. I was citing the rule in my head (the "must slide" part especially) when I watched this live last night. I was very surprised it did not go to review since FPSR fits under that umbrella and the CC was the third base umpire and could have initiated it right away. That was too big a situation not to take a look and make sure 100% they got it right (IF they got it right).
  10. I do it in every direction. I've had D1 and pro guys promote this as preventative officiating. Hell, you can hear MLB guys doing it when miked up during the postseason. This tells the catcher and the hitter exactly where a pitch is missing, and if need be, the wannabe snipers in the dugout. If they still question it and I gave where it missed verbally, I'll use the catcher to relay the message for me. That can make it look like we're working together and I don't have to yell it into a dugout, which I address at the conference prior to every game, "We're not going to be yelling across the diamond at each other."
  11. No catch. On a snowcone grab like this, anything that comes out following without 100% secure possession is going to be no catch. The ball was out before the hand reached the glove. IMOP this was not a flip. Poor timing.
  12. CCA Manual "Standards fro Removal from Game" 1. Use of profanity specifically directed at an umpire or vulgar personal insults of an umpire, including accusations of bias or cheating are grounds for an immediate ejection (NCAA 2-25). The pitcher stating, "That's horrible" can easily be held as a personal insult, but it's a stretch to classify it as vulgar. Does anyone know if a ball/strike warning was given to Louisville earlier in the game? You would think the NCAA would have included that information in their release from Randy Bruns, but it did not. If that warning was given, then there was grounds for immediate ejection in that case as well. Overall from what we know as fact, which the article does great job of elaborating, it seem there were definitely technical grounds for ejection, BUT, some good preventative officiating could have de-escalated the situation without the result of all the negative attention this is getting.
  13. I believe in baseball you may also substitute a pinch runner to complete the 4-base award if the BR cannot complete the trip without penalty.
  14. R3, I'm always going to stay in shallow C, regardless of outs. However, R2/R3 and 2 outs only, I will slip back into a deep B if it's a higher level of competition. My reasoning behind this is (1) IMOP, better teams are exponentially more likely to back pick at second base, not third, and (2) I can slide inside or outside on a routine ground ball in a much better position. In a deep B, I'm only a drop step or two back and I'm getting a really good look on that runner coming back into second base. I do sacrifice a bit of the distance on R3, but can take a step or two to improve my angle if needed. I'm quite aware that this is unorthodox and goes against the CCA Manual, but confident in working it this way and pregame it with my partners so they're prepared.
  15. Much better look and feel to these shirts. I'm not so sure the collar is all that different though like it's advertised. I wore it behind the dish the first wear and looked JACKED! Ha.
×
×
  • Create New...