I was going to stay out of this "to-saw-or-not-to-saw" debate, but I thought I'd just relay this incident as some food for thought. A young fellow umpire I know who'd been umpiring for nearly 8 years got a wild hair last year and removed the throat guard from his mask because of (as he put it) "the cool factor". He hung a Mizuno spider on it and used it regularly for HS Varsity and adult rec ball for a few weeks until one day, while calling an adult game, a 92 mph fastball was fouled back and hit the upper part of the dangler near its attachment point...the attachment on one side of the throat guard failed and the spider was driven into his larynx at an angle. His larynx was fractured and (thank God) the home team's 3rd baseman happened to be a medical doctor who was able to perform an emergency tracheotomy on him almost immediately. He was rushed to the hospital a few minutes later and recovered after a few weeks. This umpire never called another game after that, and his voice has been permanently affected. I can't help but to think that if the mask had been left intact, he probably would've only had his bell rung and perhaps a sore jaw...but nothing life threatening requiring an ambulance ride to the hospital. I realize we're all big boys (and girls) here and can decide for ourselves which risks we choose to take as far as equipment goes. I don't wanna preach. I mean, I myself can't get used to wearing a dangler at all, so I rely on the mask's throat protection bars. Sawing those off wouldn't work for me, cos then I'd have no protection at all. But I agree with @maineump when he says that the integrated throat guard is much safer than any dangler. And if you have both, that's an extra degree of protection.