Register or Sign In to remove these ads


  • Content count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by MT73

  1. No, that is not what J Murray said. He said if the ball was kicked or touched by the batter while exiting the box he would call him out. (Personally I would not call him out unless contact with the ball was made a step or two out of the box.) Yes--even if the ball first hits the plate--or in front of the plate-- and then strikes the batter while standing in the box it is a foul ball. PS--I think Kevin_K's post has put this thread to bed. Thank you.
  2. I blame the umpire. Now fix it.
  3. Last week.. Batter hits a foul ball to the backstop. Catcher throws it back to the pitcher but it goes over his head. R3 scores. I send him back. Coach states that on a foul ball the runner has the right to advance on an over throw. I tell him he is wrong. Suppose he wanted to show me a rule book to support his ( ridiculous) position? Should I entertain his lunacy for the sake of field decorum? Your OP is just as ridiculous to everyone except you. Yes, we all know that a part of the batter's box is in fair territory. But as long as the hit foot is within the box when he is struck it is a foul ball. Deal with it. PS--it is a rare manager/coach who "knows the rules" PPS-learn the rules/interpretations or forever be at the mercy of ignorant coaches.
  4. So what happens on this play in Fed?
  5. Come out on my field with a rule book and you are gone. Yes, I will warn you. Yes, I will tell you my ruling and you may protest the game but do not thrust a rule book under my nose. Now get back to the dugout or the next step is the parking lot.
  6. Bring a rule book onto my field and you are gone. I do not do LL but it is common knowledge that if a batter is in the box and gets hit with his batted ball--even if his feet are in the fair portion of the box--then it is a foul ball. In 50 years of watching, playing, coaching and umpiring baseball I have never seen this questioned.
  7. Since a foul is a dead ball I would say that anything that happens after it is irrelevant.
  8. Are you sure the local rules allow 8 players? If so then yes, automatic out.
  9. I agree.
  10. Suppose it was two outs, bases loaded and R1 was called out on the tag before R3 scored. In OBR would the run count?
  11. Yes, looking at it again his foot does cross the plate after the swing. Good call by the umpire.
  12. I thought backswing / follow through interference was only an out in FED. According to page 80, section 7.14 of the 2015 Minor League Umpires Manual the proper call on this play is a dead ball strike and runner returned to 1B. " This interpretation applies even if the catcher is in the act of making a throw to retire a runner. That is if the batter is in the batters box and his normal backswing or follow through unintentionally strikes the catcher or the ball while the catcher is in the act of throwing "Time" is called and runners return ( unless catcher's throw retires the runner) "
  13. OBR and HS rulesets: B/R is obstructed while heading to second base and the obstruction prevents him from touching the bag. He continues on to third and defense appeals that he missed 2B. Would that appeal be granted?
  14. I just picked up a 1985 copy of Joe Brinkman's book and one question has me very confused: Bases loaded two outs and batter hits a home run. How many runs score in the following situations: A) R2 misses 3rd and is called out on appeal. B) R2 is called out for missing home plate C) R1 is called out on appeal for missing 3rd base D) R1 is called out on appeal for missing home plate. E) B/R is called out for missing 2nd base F) The B/R is called out for missing first base. Answers 0,1,2,2,3,0 I thought that in an appeal situation with 2 outs an appeal on a force would negate all runs. Which is why I put down 0 for every situation except for E so I guess I am wrong. Can someone please explain the logic/reasoning to all of these situations? Thanks.
  15. Ahh--thank you!!!
  16. The mechanic was changed for the 2016 season as stated in the 2016 MLBUM and they even state that this may indeed tip off the defense. I am wondering if we should make the change in youth ball or just call it as we used to?
  17. Am brushing up on my 3rd world plays. Bases loaded, 2 outs. Batter hits home run but misses second base Who scores? Suppose any runner misses a base in a 2 out bases loaded situation Would this be considered a force situation and negate any runs? If not is there a formula we can apply, such as all runners in front of the runner who missed the base score? Thanks in advance.
  18. I suppose if the runner was just feinting to third it could be considered an issue.
  19. Thanks to all.
  20. My wife is from the Lund area in Skane Is baseball popular in Sweden?
  21. Yes, all runners were forced as soon as the batter hit the grounder.
  22. I used to be careful about calling Obstruction in FED because I thought an extra base was mandatory no matter what. After reading this case play I realize that is not the case, which makes sense since he was not actually hindered while trying for an extra base Thanks for posting.
  23. Mr.

    There is a case play on this in OBR. Dead Ball. Strike 3, batter out and the run does not score.
  24. Mr.

    In OBR it is A. R1 would have been awarded second base even if he was not stealing because all runners would have been awarded one base from TOP.
  25. Actually happened in my sons 12U game: Bases loaded no out. Batter hits pop up, umpires call infield fly. Fielder drops the ball and all runners take off. Multible attempts to make outs but team cant make any. Last runner scores because B/R--who is already out on IF -- gets in a rundown between first and second base. Question--is this interference by the BR?