Jump to content

ElkOil

Members
  • Content count

    1,685
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    19

ElkOil last won the day on August 20

ElkOil had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

698 Good

About ElkOil

  • Birthday 01/28/1970

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male

More information about you

  • Types/Levels of Baseball called
    PONY, Premier, High School, MSBL
  • How did you hear about Umpire-Empire?
    Search Engine (Google, Yahoo, Bing, ...)

Recent Profile Visitors

4,243 profile views
  1. Kneeling for National Anthem

    Therein lies the rub. Who's definition of "right" do we use? Those who kneel know in their hearts they are right. Those who condemn their actions wholeheartedly believe that they, too, are right. You cannot and should not legislate what is right in this scenario. We are all left having to agree to disagree and live and let live. And while I agree with your post and your sentiment, it is the Constitutionally-protected right of the kneelers to kneel and the right of those to speak out against them to do so. Maybe exercising those rights is the "right" you seek? Because that's the only way we can all be "right."
  2. I certainly will. But the only reason is because you told me to.
  3. Kinda sounds like splitting hairs to divide the slide between the two umpires. As PU, I'm watching the whole thing and will make a call accordingly. When I'm BU, I'll call it if I see it assuming my partner doesn''t.
  4. So get the out at 2B, then while I continue to look at 2B, call the runner out at 1B? Got it. I'll be sure to do this next time.
  5. I turned after I made the out call at 2B to make the out call at 1B, regardless of when the ball and runner arrived since the out at 1B was automatic. Once you determine the slide at 2B is illegal, you don't have to see what happens at 1B.
  6. PU's job is to watch the slide, while BU's is to get the safe/out at both bases. Many guys I've worked with aren't students enough of umpiring to know this, unfortunately, so I'm sure to pre-game it with them so they know they have to watch the slide. Having said that, when I'm BU I've made the illegal slide call on a couple of occasions since it was early enough before I turned for the DP.
  7. ElkOil

  8. So back to my other question... why wouldn't you call INT on this?
  9. With batter INT, for example, one of the criteria we use to determine if INT occurred is if the catcher's throw didn't retire a runner. Wouldn't the same be true here? Since the throw to 1B didn't retire the runner, wouldn't we call INT? After my first viewing, I could see myself making the double play call.
  10. new umpire

    Did the umpire indicate it was, or is there a question about how the call was handled? To the technical aspects of the situation, it's an infield fly if the following criteria are met: 1. Less than two out. 2. Force play in effect at 3B ( so bases loaded or runners on 1B and 2B). 3. Fly ball is hit (as @noumpere said, it has to be high enough in the umpire's judgement). No infield fly is in effect on a bunted ball. 4. An infielder must be able to catch it using ordinary effort. Note that this does not mean it has to be caught by an infielder nor does it mean that the ball is over the infield.
  11. What to look for here?

    I gotta disagree on this, which becomes particularly important at the levels of ball we all call. Selling this call is more important on our fields than an MLB diamond since they just go to video review if someone disagrees. In this video, U1 was anything but set. He casually walked into position, remained upright, sort of wavered around while the play was happening, then gave an extremely quick safe call. Right, wrong or otherwise, any coach at our levels would be right to think we missed it because we weren't set and our timing was off. So to the OP, I suggest that this is less about what we look at, since everyone else already gave good input about how difficult that is on this play, and more about the fundamentals of hustling into position, getting set like you're ready, taking that extra second, then selling your call. Since we can't go to video, that's all we got.
  12. Show me where I said it was, Rich. I never so much as implied it. What IS squarely in the purview of the umpire is game management, including calling time when necessary -- even if the batter didn't request it. The umpire's need for a time out is as valid as anyone else's. That was my only point relative to the OP. And as for my point relative to you, get some training, gear up, get behind the plate and stay active on this forum. Then you'll understand our frustration when you read posts from people like who you were before. Instead of criticizing our ranks, join them.
  13. Looks like Hallion was flirting with the Yellow Zone.
×